Skip to content

Evidence Engine · WI-EV v1.7.0

What changed, and when.

A living evidence synthesis is only trustworthy if its changes are visible. Every recomputation that altered a conclusion, a score or a confidence band is written here, permanently, in the order it happened.

Revisions published

120

Claims revised

14

Latest change

2026-11-01

2026-11-01

CLT fire · version 19

Charring rates of cross-laminated timber under standard fire exposure are predictable within the Eurocode 5 design assumptions.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 24 studies

Larch · version 14

Untreated larch cladding reaches a service life comparable to surface-treated softwood in temperate Northern European climates.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 19 studies

Detailing · version 18

Design detailing that keeps water off end grain affects the service life of exterior wood more than moving one EN 350 durability class.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 53 studies

Coating maintenance · version 15

Regular maintenance of a film-forming coating extends the service life of exterior timber cladding more than the initial coating choice does.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 53 studies

Moisture · version 20

Sustained wood moisture content above 25 percent is the controlling condition for fungal decay initiation in above-ground timber.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (2 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 46 studies

Mass timber · version 18

Mass timber assemblies carry a higher built-in moisture risk during construction than they do in service.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (2 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 48 studies

Silicate treatment · version 17

Silicate-based surface treatments measurably slow the surface weathering of exterior softwood.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 1 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 4 studies

Acetylation · version 19

Acetylation reduces the moisture-driven dimensional movement of wood by more than half relative to the untreated species.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 20 studies

Preservative treatment · version 14

Preservative-treated Scots pine sapwood reaches the intended service life in EN 335 use class 3 exposure.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 13 studies

Test methods · version 24

Accelerated laboratory weathering tests reliably predict field performance of exterior wood coatings.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Contradicted. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (1 support, 3 contradict). Evidence strength 45/100; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

45

Low confidence

8% consensus · 56 studies

Decay modelling · version 17

The Scheffer climate index is a reliable predictor of above-ground decay hazard across climate zones.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (3 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength 45/100; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

45

Low confidence

100% consensus · 41 studies

Thermal modification · version 21

Thermal modification measurably increases the decay resistance of softwood in above-ground exterior use.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (14 support, 1 contradict). Evidence strength 52/100; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

52

Low confidence

98% consensus · 32 studies

Substitution · version 21

Substituting timber for mineral structural materials reduces the cradle-to-gate greenhouse gas emissions of a building.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (12 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength 55/100; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

55

Low confidence

100% consensus · 65 studies

Carbon · version 20

Long-lived timber construction products deliver a net biogenic carbon storage benefit over the building service life.

WI-EV v1.7.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (14 support, 2 contradict). Evidence strength 58/100; moderate confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

58

Moderate confidence

85% consensus · 55 studies

2026-10-30

2026-10-19

2026-10-17

2026-10-15

2026-10-14

Acetylation · version 18

Acetylation reduces the moisture-driven dimensional movement of wood by more than half relative to the untreated species.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 20 studies

Detailing · version 17

Design detailing that keeps water off end grain affects the service life of exterior wood more than moving one EN 350 durability class.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 53 studies

CLT fire · version 18

Charring rates of cross-laminated timber under standard fire exposure are predictable within the Eurocode 5 design assumptions.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 24 studies

Preservative treatment · version 13

Preservative-treated Scots pine sapwood reaches the intended service life in EN 335 use class 3 exposure.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 13 studies

Mass timber · version 16

Mass timber assemblies carry a higher built-in moisture risk during construction than they do in service.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (2 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 47 studies

Coating maintenance · version 14

Regular maintenance of a film-forming coating extends the service life of exterior timber cladding more than the initial coating choice does.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 53 studies

Silicate treatment · version 16

Silicate-based surface treatments measurably slow the surface weathering of exterior softwood.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 1 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 4 studies

Moisture · version 18

Sustained wood moisture content above 25 percent is the controlling condition for fungal decay initiation in above-ground timber.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (2 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 48 studies

Larch · version 13

Untreated larch cladding reaches a service life comparable to surface-treated softwood in temperate Northern European climates.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Unclear. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (0 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 19 studies

Test methods · version 22

Accelerated laboratory weathering tests reliably predict field performance of exterior wood coatings.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Contradicted. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (1 support, 3 contradict). Evidence strength 45/100; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

45

Low confidence

8% consensus · 57 studies

Decay modelling · version 15

The Scheffer climate index is a reliable predictor of above-ground decay hazard across climate zones.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (3 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength 45/100; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

45

Low confidence

100% consensus · 42 studies

Thermal modification · version 19

Thermal modification measurably increases the decay resistance of softwood in above-ground exterior use.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (14 support, 1 contradict). Evidence strength 52/100; moderate confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

52

Moderate confidence

98% consensus · 32 studies

Substitution · version 20

Substituting timber for mineral structural materials reduces the cradle-to-gate greenhouse gas emissions of a building.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (12 support, 0 contradict). Evidence strength 55/100; low confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

55

Low confidence

100% consensus · 65 studies

Carbon · version 18

Long-lived timber construction products deliver a net biogenic carbon storage benefit over the building service life.

WI-EV v1.6.0: Supported. Direction calculated from existing weighted primary studies (14 support, 2 contradict). Evidence strength 58/100; moderate confidence. Verdict thresholds: two-thirds weighted support or opposition, otherwise Mixed; fewer than three directional studies = Unclear. Score arithmetic, classifications and confidence thresholds unchanged. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

58

Moderate confidence

85% consensus · 54 studies

Detailing · version 16

Design detailing that keeps water off end grain affects the service life of exterior wood more than moving one EN 350 durability class.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 53 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 53 studies

Preservative treatment · version 12

Preservative-treated Scots pine sapwood reaches the intended service life in EN 335 use class 3 exposure.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 13 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 13 studies

Moisture · version 17

Sustained wood moisture content above 25 percent is the controlling condition for fungal decay initiation in above-ground timber.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 48 relevant primary studies, 2 directional (1 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 1 new study indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 48 studies

Coating maintenance · version 13

Regular maintenance of a film-forming coating extends the service life of exterior timber cladding more than the initial coating choice does.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 53 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 53 studies

Mass timber · version 15

Mass timber assemblies carry a higher built-in moisture risk during construction than they do in service.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 47 relevant primary studies, 2 directional (1 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 47 studies

Larch · version 12

Untreated larch cladding reaches a service life comparable to surface-treated softwood in temperate Northern European climates.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 19 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 19 studies

Silicate treatment · version 15

Silicate-based surface treatments measurably slow the surface weathering of exterior softwood.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 4 relevant primary studies, 1 directional (1 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 4 studies

CLT fire · version 17

Charring rates of cross-laminated timber under standard fire exposure are predictable within the Eurocode 5 design assumptions.

WI-EV v1.5.0: method claim — studies re-tiered as validation against observed outcomes (0 directional), comparison with another model (0 directional) or application without validation (never directional, 0 relevant). Original source excluded from directional evidence (circularity rule): 0. 0 directional studies. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 24 studies

Acetylation · version 17

Acetylation reduces the moisture-driven dimensional movement of wood by more than half relative to the untreated species.

WI-EV v1.5.0: tiers re-checked; above-ground field studies (EN 330, L-joint, lap-joint, double-layer, in-service surveys) are tier (a) for above-ground claims. 20 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 20 studies

Decay modelling · version 14

The Scheffer climate index is a reliable predictor of above-ground decay hazard across climate zones.

WI-EV v1.5.0: method claim — studies re-tiered as validation against observed outcomes (2 directional), comparison with another model (1 directional) or application without validation (never directional, 0 relevant). Original source excluded from directional evidence (circularity rule): 1. 3 directional studies. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

45

Low confidence

100% consensus · 42 studies

Test methods · version 20

Accelerated laboratory weathering tests reliably predict field performance of exterior wood coatings.

WI-EV v1.5.0: method claim — studies re-tiered as validation against observed outcomes (4 directional), comparison with another model (0 directional) or application without validation (never directional, 0 relevant). Original source excluded from directional evidence (circularity rule): 1. 4 directional studies. No score was set by hand. 1 new study indexed, Evidence strength -1 to 45.

45

Low confidence

8% consensus · 56 studies

Detailing · version 15

Design detailing that keeps water off end grain affects the service life of exterior wood more than moving one EN 350 durability class.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (16), 4 duplicate records merged. 54 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 54 studies

Coating maintenance · version 12

Regular maintenance of a film-forming coating extends the service life of exterior timber cladding more than the initial coating choice does.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (10), 9 duplicate records merged. 53 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 53 studies

Larch · version 11

Untreated larch cladding reaches a service life comparable to surface-treated softwood in temperate Northern European climates.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (4), 1 duplicate record merged. 19 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 19 studies

CLT fire · version 16

Charring rates of cross-laminated timber under standard fire exposure are predictable within the Eurocode 5 design assumptions.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (4), 0 duplicate records merged. 24 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 24 studies

Acetylation · version 16

Acetylation reduces the moisture-driven dimensional movement of wood by more than half relative to the untreated species.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (6), 2 duplicate records merged. 20 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 20 studies

Mass timber · version 14

Mass timber assemblies carry a higher built-in moisture risk during construction than they do in service.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (5), 3 duplicate records merged. 47 relevant primary studies, 2 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 47 studies

Preservative treatment · version 11

Preservative-treated Scots pine sapwood reaches the intended service life in EN 335 use class 3 exposure.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (0), 5 duplicate records merged. 13 relevant primary studies, 0 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 13 studies

Silicate treatment · version 14

Silicate-based surface treatments measurably slow the surface weathering of exterior softwood.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (3), 1 duplicate record merged. 4 relevant primary studies, 1 directional (1 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 4 studies

Moisture · version 16

Sustained wood moisture content above 25 percent is the controlling condition for fungal decay initiation in above-ground timber.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (13), 1 duplicate record merged. 47 relevant primary studies, 2 directional (1 field in the claim's exposure). Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. Re-swept; no change to the published figures.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 47 studies

Thermal modification · version 17

Thermal modification measurably increases the decay resistance of softwood in above-ground exterior use.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (9), 3 duplicate records merged. 32 relevant primary studies, 15 directional (3 field in the claim's exposure). No score was set by hand. Evidence strength -11 to 52, consensus 99% → 98%, confidence moderate → low.

52

Low confidence

98% consensus · 32 studies

Substitution · version 18

Substituting timber for mineral structural materials reduces the cradle-to-gate greenhouse gas emissions of a building.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (16), 2 duplicate records merged. 65 relevant primary studies, 12 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). No score was set by hand. Evidence strength -15 to 55, confidence moderate → low.

55

Low confidence

100% consensus · 65 studies

Carbon · version 16

Long-lived timber construction products deliver a net biogenic carbon storage benefit over the building service life.

WI-EV v1.4.0: studies weighted by test type (field in the claim's exposure > field elsewhere > laboratory > mechanism), reviews moved out of the directional pool (14), 3 duplicate records merged. 53 relevant primary studies, 16 directional (0 field in the claim's exposure). No score was set by hand. Evidence strength -15 to 58, consensus 87% → 85%.

58

Moderate confidence

85% consensus · 53 studies

Substitution · version 15

Substituting timber for mineral structural materials reduces the cradle-to-gate greenhouse gas emissions of a building.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 33 relevant studies, 8 directional. No score was set by hand. 9 new studies indexed, Evidence strength +6 to 63, confidence low → moderate.

63

Moderate confidence

100% consensus · 33 studies

Larch · version 9

Untreated larch cladding reaches a service life comparable to surface-treated softwood in temperate Northern European climates.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 7 relevant studies, 0 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 2 new studies indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 7 studies

Carbon · version 13

Long-lived timber construction products deliver a net biogenic carbon storage benefit over the building service life.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 37 relevant studies, 14 directional. No score was set by hand. 11 new studies indexed, Evidence strength +5 to 65, consensus 100% → 83%, confidence low → moderate.

65

Moderate confidence

83% consensus · 37 studies

Decay modelling · version 10

The Scheffer climate index is a reliable predictor of above-ground decay hazard across climate zones.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 17 relevant studies, 2 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 1 new study indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 17 studies

Preservative treatment · version 8

Preservative-treated Scots pine sapwood reaches the intended service life in EN 335 use class 3 exposure.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 3 relevant studies, 0 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 2 new studies indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 3 studies

Moisture · version 13

Sustained wood moisture content above 25 percent is the controlling condition for fungal decay initiation in above-ground timber.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 13 relevant studies, 2 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 7 new studies indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 13 studies

Mass timber · version 11

Mass timber assemblies carry a higher built-in moisture risk during construction than they do in service.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 32 relevant studies, 1 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 10 new studies indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

100% consensus · 32 studies

Detailing · version 12

Design detailing that keeps water off end grain affects the service life of exterior wood more than moving one EN 350 durability class.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 18 relevant studies, 0 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 9 new studies indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 18 studies

Coating maintenance · version 9

Regular maintenance of a film-forming coating extends the service life of exterior timber cladding more than the initial coating choice does.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 8 relevant studies, 0 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 6 new studies indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 8 studies

CLT fire · version 13

Charring rates of cross-laminated timber under standard fire exposure are predictable within the Eurocode 5 design assumptions.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 10 relevant studies, 0 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 3 new studies indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 10 studies

Acetylation · version 14

Acetylation reduces the moisture-driven dimensional movement of wood by more than half relative to the untreated species.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 8 relevant studies, 0 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 1 new study indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 8 studies

Silicate treatment · version 11

Silicate-based surface treatments measurably slow the surface weathering of exterior softwood.

WI-EV v1.3.0 recall expansion: expanded query set, IRG-WP documents and OpenAlex citation chaining; every new record passed the same wood-domain rule and relevance classifier. 1 relevant study, 1 directional. Evidence strength withheld: insufficient evidence. No score was set by hand. 1 new study indexed.

Insufficient evidence

Low confidence

0% consensus · 1 studies

2026-10-12

Scores are rule-based functions of indexed literature metadata under method WI-EV v1.7.0. A revision records a change in the published record, not a change in the underlying material behaviour.